The Hour Cosmic Presents: Our Favorite Knock-Off Characters

By , and | July 31st, 2014
Posted in Columns | % Comments

In case you missed our latest episode of The Hour Cosmic (Episode 77: Mr. Falcon and the Stranger in the Woods with Ryan Browne), we talked a lot about various TMNT rip-offs, specifically Adolescent Radioactive Black Belt Hamsters. That got us thinking – what are some of our favorite characters that started/existed as knock-offs of more famous characters? Read our picks below, and if you haven’t heard the episode yet, check it out in the embedded player, or download here.


Vince’s Pick: Jonathan Hickman’s “New Avengers” Justice League – “The Great Society”

I know this one is fairly recent, but I had a lot of fun reading Jonathan Hickman’s Marvel alt-Earth take on DC’s “Justice League” in the pages of “New Avengers” (spoilers lie ahead). They were known as the “Great Society”, which consisted of obvious homages to Superman, Batman, Wonder Woman, Green Lantern, The Flash, and Martian Manhunter. There have been so many pastiches of the Justice League over the years, but few of them were as visually and conceptually direct and obvious as Hickman’s. Most of them are really just teams full of basic archetypes that happen to carry a lot of the same traits as the Justice League – I’m thinking of parodies like “The Authority” or some of the cast of “Astro City” when I say this.

The Great Society

Hickman’s “Great Society” went directly at the “Justice League”, even going as far as to throw the name “Wayne” around without batting an eye. Their predecessors on Earth-4290001 were even called the “Archetypes of J.U.S.T.I.C.E.” so, you know, no hiding anything here.

What was most fun about the “Great Society” is that they really brought out the worst in Marvel’s Illuminati, who at the time were being forced to destroy planets to avoid incursions that would destroy their own (Marvel 616). In some ways, Hickman is both poking fun at the Justice League by having Marvel’s heroes destroy them, and honoring them by doing such a straight, well-done pastiche of them. Not only did they make for an insanely fascinating dilemma for the Marvel Illuminati, but they also continue to have me hoping for the day that Jonathan Hickman writes all the Marvel characters he wants to write and grabs a job on the actual “Justice League” title. Hey, a guy can hope, right?

Chad’s Pick: Captain Marvel, aka Shazam!

My favorite knockoff character is none other than the Big Red Cheese himself, Captain Marvel! And while I’m sure most of you don’t need a history lesson, I’ll give you one anyway.

Captain Marvel made his four color debut way back in 1940 in the pages of Fawcett Comics’ Whiz Comics #2. He was an immediate success, and within a few years of his first appearance, Cap’s titles had gone from monthly to bi-weekly, and were selling in the millions. Where comics were concerned, The World’s Mightiest Mortal was the World’s Mightiest Money-Maker, outselling every other title on the stands, including DC Comics’ Superman titles. DC sued Fawcett in 1941 for copyright infringement, claiming that Captain Marvel was too close to Superman in appearance, abilities, and overall setting. After years of litigation, appeals, and great comics, the court decided that Captain Marvel himself wasn’t infringing on DC’s copyright, but rather his powers and abilities, and in general his stories did so. Fawcett, the underdog, settled out of court with DC, and ceased publication of Captain Marvel titles entirely just a few years later. In the 1970s, in an effort to revive the beloved character, DC would license Captain Marvel from Fawcett before eventually buying their entire catalog of characters and incorporating them in the DC Universe proper by the late 1980s.

Chad is claiming this isn't coincidence

Now, I have a lot mixed feelings about the way DC acquired the Fawcett characters, but putting all that aside for a moment, it’s pretty obvious that Captain Marvel was a blatant knockoff of Superman. The physical similarities alone are dead giveaways, but when you start to consider things like Billy Batson’s profession (reporter), his villains (Dr. Sivana, the bald mad scientist), and his Lieutenant Marvels Mary Marvel and Captain Marvel Jr., the argument just gets harder and harder to make.

Continued below

But then again, who’s arguing? Certainly not me. I don’t care who Fawcett had to ripoff to get us Captain Marvel, so long as they did!

Brian’s Pick: Elongated Man

The setting: 1960, the offices of DC Comics. Editor Julius Schwartz doesn’t realize that DC owns the name and rights for Plastic Man, and so creates a new version of, essentially, the same character to be a supporting player in the Flash. What started from such inauspicious beginnings went on to be one of the most fully realized characters DC introduced during the Silver Age.

Faux-Life cover by Gene Gonzlaez

Ralph Dibny went from being the third most famous stretchy character in comics to being one half of, perhaps, the greatest love story in the medium. He was a Justice Leaguer in good time and bad, he was one of the first heroes to “go public” with their identity, and he struggled with grief in a way we rarely see. He took center stage in “52,” and his story added the human anchor that really made that story work.

And – those who know me will not be surprised by this – he had a great supporting role in “Starman,” which is the closest anyone can come to a free pass to do anything they like in my book.

In fact, this is the rare knock-off that has become a more beloved, more utilized, more well-rounded character than the original. Sure, Plastic Man has the name recognition, but I don’t think anyone would claim that he is as essential a part of DC’s Silver and Bronze age (or any age, really), than Dibny is, even though he hasn’t appeared in a comic in nearly a decade.

Our guest on our next episode is none other than Dennis Hopeless, the writer of “Avengers Undercover” and the upcoming “Spider-Woman” series! Make sure to follow @TheHourCosmic and retweet this tweet for a chance to have Dennis play on your behalf and win a prize!

Thanks for checking this out, and come back to hear Dennis on the show on Monday!

//TAGS | The Hour Cosmic

Brian Salvatore

Brian Salvatore is an editor, podcaster, reviewer, writer at large, and general task master at Multiversity. When not writing, he can be found playing music, hanging out with his kids, or playing music with his kids. He also has a dog named Lola, a rowboat, and once met Jimmy Carter. Feel free to email him about good beer, the New York Mets, or the best way to make Chicken Parmagiana (add a thin slice of prosciutto under the cheese).


Chad Bowers

Chad Bowers has been reading comics for most of his life. His transition from fan to professional is a work in progress. He’s the co-founder of ACTION AGE COMICS, creator of the webcomic MONSTER PLUS, co-creator of AWESOME HOSPITAL, THE HARD ONES, and DOWN SET FIGHT (coming soon from Oni Press) with Chris Sims. He reviews comics, writes G.I. JoeVersity, and co-hosts The Hour Cosmic for Multiversity Comics! If you've got nothing better to do, you can follow him on Twitter or Tumblr.


Vince Ostrowski

Dr. Steve Brule once called him "A typical hunk who thinks he knows everything about comics." Twitter: @VJ_Ostrowski


  • Podcasts
    The Hour Cosmic, Episode 81: Flame-Heads with Andy Hirsch [Podcast]

    By and | Sep 2, 2014 | Podcasts

    Welcome to another installment of The Hour Cosmic, your favorite comics game show! This week, our guest is “Garfield” artist, Andy Hirsch!On this week’s show, among other things, we discuss:– Everyone’s favorite orange cat!– Everyone’s least favorite day!– Everyone’s favorite baked pasta! Let’s meet our guest, shall we?Andy Hirsch is the artist on Boom’s “Garfield.” […]

    MORE »
    The Hour Cosmic, Episode 80: Pug Con with Mike Norton [Podcast]

    By , and | Aug 19, 2014 | Podcasts

    Welcome to another installment of The Hour Cosmic, your favorite comics game show! This week, our guest is “Revival” and “Battlepug” artist Mike Norton!On this week’s show, among other things, we discuss:– The mysterious world of Pug Conventions!– Mike’s (almost) total lack of memory of working with Kid Loki!– Matt’s obsession with the origin of […]

    MORE »