Remembering Amalgam: “Challengers of the Fantastic” #1

By | September 14th, 2020
Posted in Reviews | % Comments

The retro review journey through Amalgam continues today with “Challengers of the Fantastic”, a team teased in 1996’s “Spider Boy” and featuring a kinda-sorta sub-plot crossover with 1997’s “Spider-Boy Team Up”.

The Mash Up
On one side, you have the four-person team created by Jack Kirby for DC in 1957, the Challengers of the Unknown. On the other, you have the four-person team created by Jack Kirby and Stan Lee for Marvel in 1960, the Fantastic Four. Their combination is natural, maybe even poetic.

This issue was written by Karl Kesel, the same creator who introduced the team as supporting characters in the “Spider-Boy” issue a year earlier. He was aided by penciller Tom Grummett and inker Al Vey. This Amalgam was published by Marvel.

The plot
The story is told in four parts. The first part is a brief “re-telling” of the team’s origin. Essentially, it’s the Fantastic Four origin, except they don’t get superpowers. They just survive the cosmic rays and decide to continue challenging other fantastic situations. For some reason, they adopt an hourglass as their logo.

In Chapter 1, we catch up on where the team is in the present day. The only important change is that Johnny “Red” Storm has a miniature clone of himself that rides on his shoulder talking to him. (Note: this was done two years before Austin Powers made it popular with Mini Me in The Spy Who Shagged Me.) They group is visited by Uatu the Guardian (he got better), who warns them that Galacticiac is coming. On their way to stop Galactiac, they meet the Asgodian avatar of death, the Silver Racer (Silver Surfer + New God Black Racer), who is there because someone’s about to die.

In Chapter 2, Galactiac (Galactus + Braniac) is setting up his world eating machine, but he needs to shrink part of the planet to preserve first. While they talk to him a bit, Uatu transports Johnny elsewhere, because only he can save the day. Galactiac gets mad at the other Challengers and blasts Rocky Grimm, turning him into the four-armed Thing seen on the cover.

In Chapter 3, there’s a fight, Johnny does something in what looks like another dimension, but it’s not at all clear. Reed Richards borrows Doctor Octavious’ tentacles to fight the Thing. Stuff happens, there’s a flash of light, and Galactiac is beaten. His head ejects into space, promising revenge. Johnny returns to the group and reveals it was his tiny clone that saved the day, sacrificing himself in the process. Meanwhile, Doctor Doomsday (remember him?) captures the Silver Racer and steals his powers.

What “Wizard” thought then
In the “Spider-Boy” book, there was a subplot about the Reed slowly turning evil. In this book, there’s a line of dialogue that clarifies he’s been cured. “Wizard” calls this continuity clean up, and it’s later cited as an example of why fans weren’t as interested in Amalgam the second time around – not that the clean up was unappreciated, but as evidence the Amalgam experiment was disjointed and shortsighted when compared to something like DC’s Tangent Universe, where the series of one-shots built a richer tapestry because they shared a common foundation.

Sales-wise, “Challengers of the Fantastic” fell in the middle of the pack. It was the tenth highest ordered comic for the month of April 1997, and the fifth highest ordered Amalgam.

What I think now
The combination may have been obvious, but the execution was weak. Who thought it would be a good idea to retell the Fantastic Four origin and leave out the most exciting part? Wouldn’t it make more sense to give the Challengers characters the powers of the Fantastic Four than to give the Fantastic Four characters the normalcy of the Challengers? I guess there’s brand recognition to consider, but this is the only Amalgam I’ve encountered where the combination is designed to be less fun than the originals.

Moving on, how about the coloring job on that cover? Mid-90s computer coloring at it’s finest! The gradient on the hand makes it look 3D. The fire from the flamethrower has a crazy electrical effect. And the texture on that dirt… man! It was top of the line then, but it sure looks dated now.

Continued below

The story itself is very paint-by-numbers. There are no big twists – it’s just a basic retelling of the Galactus Trilogy, down to the Silver Racer being talked into opposing Galactiac by June Masters, the Amalgam of Alicia Masters and… June from Challengers of the Unknown, I guess? The whole adventure Johnny goes on is only done because Stan and Jack did it first. Neither the location nor the purpose are ever made clear. Coming from the same writer who gave us the innovative “Spider-Boy Team-Up”, that’s a real disappointment.

Speaking of “Spider-Boy Team-Up”, I’m not sure I get the point of the crossover between the two. In “Team-Up”, the hero’s supporting cast see the Silver Racer arrive. In “Challengers of the Fantastic”, the team sees Spider-Boy’s supporting cast unconscious. Both books feature editorial notes pointing the reader to the other book for more details. I guess this is supposed to be similar to early Marvels?

Grummett’s art makes up for some of the book’s weaknesses. The action is easy to follow and his Amalgam designs are nice.

I can only assume he expected the sequence with Johnny doing stuff on his own would be explained better through captions. I hate to harp on that one sequence again and again because it was only four panels, but it was the deux ex machina and it just… happens. He shows up somewhere, hits a blue line with fire, then points his weapon at a “device”. He does, and there’s a blinding flash of light, and then it’s over.

In the end, this is an attempt at an homage to the original “Fantastic Four” stories that fails to add anything new. The only thing holding it up is the knowledge its readers bring to it in advance. If there was a second issue, I’d leave it on the stands.

//TAGS | 2020 Summer Comics Binge

Drew Bradley

Drew Bradley is a long time comic reader whose past contributions to Multiversity include the Minding MIND MGMT, Small Press Spotlight, and Tradewaiter columns, along with Lettering Week and Variant Coverage. He currently writes history-based articles. Feel free to email him about these things, or any other comic related topic.


  • Reviews
    Remembering Amalgam: JLX Unleashed #1

    By | Nov 16, 2020 | Reviews

    As the journey through Amalgam Comics nears a conclusion, I find myself at “JLX Unleashed”, the follow up to the disappointing 1996 “JLX”. Luckily for everyone, this story is a significant improvement.The Mash UpSome of the lesser members of the Justice League have been mixed with the X-Men, and in Amalgam continuity the team pits […]

    MORE »
    Remembering Amalgam: Dark Claw Adventures #1

    By | Nov 9, 2020 | Reviews

    With this review of 1997’s “Dark Claw Adventures”, we’re nearing the finish line in our journey through Amalgam Comics.The Mash UpLike the 1996 issue “Legends of the Dark Claw”, this issue merges Batman with Wolverine. Also returning is Sparrow, the Jubilee/Robin combo. Unlike the 1996 issue, “Adventures” is drawn in the Bruce Timm style and […]

    MORE »